Butcher's Puppy Perfect Dog Food Trays

1 price from Jollyes

Butcher's Puppy Perfect Dog Food Trays

WetCompletePuppyGrain-freeFish oil
60/ 100

Score v6.1.0 · label checked 4 Oct 2026

Good points

  • 55% meat
  • Low starch, about 10% carbs
  • No ingredient deductions

First ingredients: With Beef, Chicken (35%), Beef (20%), Salmon Oil (1%), Prebiotic… All ingredients

Label checked
Meat
55%
Protein, dry weight
44%
Carbs, dry weight
~10%
kcal/100 g
85

Ingredients

Listed first: With Beef. 55% of the recipe is declared meat.

  • Meat 55%
  • Other 1%
  • No amount given 44%

With Beef, Chicken (35%), Beef (20%), Salmon Oil (1%), Prebiotic, Parsley, Rosehip, Chicory, Mint, Minerals

Meat named animal protein

Additives

Vitamin A (1250 I.U), Vitamin D3 (250 I.U), Zinc (3b605) (20mg/kg), Manganese (3b503) (2.5mg/kg), Iodine (3b202) (0.5mg/kg), Natural Cassia Gum (5g/kg)

How we read this label

First ingredient: “With Beef”. It names the animal.

Each ingredient on the label, how we read it, and the share the label gives
On the labelWe read it asShare on the label
With BeefNamed meatNot given
Chicken (35%)Named meat35%
Beef (20%)Named meat20%
Salmon Oil (1%)Fat, stock, extract or other processed ingredient1%
PrebioticOtherNot given
ParsleyVegetable, fruit or plantNot given
RosehipVegetable, fruit or plantNot given
ChicoryVegetable, fruit or plantNot given
MintVegetable, fruit or plantNot given
MineralsOtherNot given

Read automatically from the label. Spotted a misreading? Tell us

Nutrition

Protein 44% and carbs about 10%, with the water taken out.

Analysis as sold and with the water taken out
NutrientAs soldDry weight
Protein8%44%
within the usual 38 to 48% for wet foods
Fat6%33%
Carbohydrate~1.8%~10%
within the usual 9 to 21% for wet foods
Fibre0.2%1.1%
Ash2%11%
Moisture82%taken out

Carbohydrate is our estimate: what is left after the other shares. The usual range is the middle half of the wet foods we rate.

Energy85 kcal/100 gCalculated from the analysis.

Why it scores 60

Starch scored best (16.7 of 20). How it’s made scored lowest (8 of 20).

  1. How much meat?

    23.4 / 45 points
    • Meat on the label19.3 / 35 points

      55% declared meat, as weighed before cooking; full marks at 100%.

    • Protein level4.1 / 10 points

      Protein is 44.4% of the food with the water taken out. Nothing at 20% or less, full marks at 80%.

  2. How much starch?

    16.7 / 20 points

    Estimated carbohydrate: About 10% carbohydrate with the water taken out (our estimate). Full marks with no carbohydrate, none at 60% or more.

  3. How processed?

    8 / 20 points

    How it’s made: Cooked in the tin, tray or pouch: 8 of 20.

  4. What kind of meat?

    12 / 15 points
    • How the meat is listed12 / 12 points

      The label lists the meat as fresh, which earns 100% of these points. Fresh or raw named meat earns all of them, dried 70%, meal half, hydrolysed a quarter, an unnamed category none.

    • Organ meat0 / 3 points

      No organ meat named.

No ingredient deductions.

Each bar is as long as the points it is worth, out of 100 in all.

Against other wet foods

Tied 329th of 639 wet foods. 38 foods share this score. Each bar counts the ranked wet foods in a 5-point step of score.

What the score means

One scale for every food: meat (45 points), starch (20), how it’s made (20) and kind of meat (15), minus points for a few listed ingredients. It rates the recipe, not your dog.

75 and over is excellent, 60 to 74 good, 45 to 59 fair and under 45 weak.

How we rate foods →

Ingredient notes

2 noted, none cost points: mint and parsley. 12 flagged nothing.

  • 2 noted
  • 12 nothing flagged
  • 1 not in our ingredient database yet
12 ingredients with nothing flagged

Beef, cassia gum, chicken, chicory root extract, minerals, rosehips, salmon oil

Allowed up to a legal maximum, none declared above it: iodine, manganese, vitamin A (retinyl acetate), vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol), zinc

Checked against the EU Catalogue of Feed Materials and FEDIAF guidelines.

Sources for these ingredients
1 not in our ingredient database yet

Prebiotic

Not in our ingredient database yet, so no judgement either way.

Notes come from published sources about each ingredient, not about this food. How we decide

Prices

One shop we track sells this: Jollyes. Checked 4 Oct 2026. Down 15% since 10 Aug.

In stock first, cheapest per kg first, excluding deliveryExcluding delivery

Sold in multipacks. Prices are for the whole pack.

Prices from each shop
ShopPackPricePer kgLink
Jollyes24 x 150g · £12.7524 x 150g£12.75£3.54/kgVisit

Since 10 Aug (2 readings): Jollyes down 15%.

Show the chart
View the readings as a table
Every reading we have, newest first
DayShopPackPricePer kg
4 Oct 2026Jollyes24 x 150g£12.75£3.54/kg
10 Aug 2026Jollyes24 x 150g£15.00£4.17/kg

Your dog

Cost per day and grams for your dog

Alternatives

4 wet foods score 8 to 13 points higher and cost up to 11% more.

Compare side by side →
Meat
75% this food 55%
Carbs
about 0% this food about 10%
To feed
38% less per 1,000 kcal

+13 pointsCompare

Meat
68% this food 55%
Carbs
about 5% this food about 10%
To feed
8% more per 1,000 kcal

+9 pointsCompare

Meat
80% this food 55%
Carbs
about 11% this food about 10%
To feed
26% less per 1,000 kcal

+8 pointsCompare

Meat
60% this food 55%
Carbs
about 7% this food about 10%
To feed
11% more per 1,000 kcal

+8 pointsCompare

Carbs are a share of the dry food, with the water taken out.

Sources

Read from 1 shop, saved 4 Oct 2026.

Page we read, saved 4 Oct 2026: Jollyes.

Score method v6.1.0 · ingredient notes v2.4.0

Report a mistake

Tell us about your dog

Saved only in this browser. Your dog’s details are never sent to us or to any retailer.

Picking a breed suggests a typical adult weight; you can still adjust it below.
What do they eat?Pick the types to look at. Leave blank to see every type.
Anything to leave out?Checked against the whole ingredient list.
What matters most?Foods the maker made for it come first.